Skip to main content

The Disturbing History of Lobotomies

by Gerselle Koh


In the TV series Ratched, Dr Hanover performed a lobotomy in an open theatre, with the presence of both the press and the governor. Originally, he attempted the procedure with a drill, but after receiving strong reactions to the copious amounts of blood, he opted for the more 'sophisticated' technique of inserting an ice pick into the top of an eye socket. If you thought that scene in Ratched where Hanover gave a lobotomy with an ice pick was an artistic exaggeration - it wasn't. That's how Walter Freeman, a populariser of lobotomies in the 1940s, performed thousands of operations.


Neurologists António Egas Moniz and Walter Freeman are usually credited with inventing the lobotomy in the 1930s, though their work was largely based on Swiss psychiatrist Gottlieb Burckhardt, who performed some of the first psychosurgeries on patients' frontal lobes and other parts of their brains in the 1880s. While Burckhardt intended for the utility of the surgery to be ‘at most palliative,’ his research was harshly rejected by the medical community for being disturbing and ineffective. 


To further refine Burckhardt’s surgical technique, Moniz developed a more specific process called the leucotomy, which involved inserting a small surgical rod with a retractable wire loop into the brain. The procedure began to gain acceptance as a primary treatment for psychiatric diseases - even though Moniz kept poor records of patient follow-ups and even returned some patients to asylums postoperatively. 


The procedure was also introduced to neurologist Walter Freeman and neurosurgeon James Watts, who championed this migration, aiming to improve on the results of their international colleagues. They modified the procedure so that it required nothing more than a small 1 cm burr hole that could be drilled for the insertion of the leucotome. This undoubtedly made the procedure less invasive, but it still came with the postoperative risks of seizure disorders, infections, and even death.


One of the most notable lobotomy patients is Rosemary Kennedy, the sister of former US President John F. Kennedy. During her birth, a nurse held her inside the birth canal for two hours, which caused oxygen deprivation and resulted in a mental deficiency. She was described as irritable and rebellious, and her father sought the advice of none other than Freeman and Watts. Eventually, her father authorised her lobotomy, which not only failed to cure her intellectual disabilities, but also left Rosemary with permanent physical and mental disabilities, completely unable to live independently up to her death. 


Despite many failed procedures, they published articles about their work in prestigious scientific journals, reporting that patients who had been violent or suicidal, were calmed down immeasurably by the surgery. In a 1942 presentation at the New York Academy of Medicine, Freeman and Watts reported that after a lobotomy, patients did sometimes become ‘indolent’ or ‘outspoken.’ In truth, patients were often left incontinen and paralysed. Their first prefrontal lobotomy was on a woman named Alice Hood Hammatt who reported that she felt happy when she awoke from the procedure. But six days later, she reported experiencing language difficulties, disorientation, and agitation. 


Their work had simplified the lobotomy so much that Freeman began performing the procedure without the help of his colleague and without the sterile field that was often required in the operating room. This distanced Watts from the research, as he was disturbed by the crude nature of the transorbital approach. In time, the two severed their ties, but Freeman continued with his passionate crusade to popularise the transorbital lobotomy throughout North America. 


However, Freeman held peculiar beliefs about the psychological makeup and social influences of people of color, and these affected his treatment of patients. He believed that African American patients, especially women, were among the best candidates for lobotomy because of what he called “the greater family solidarity manifested by these people.” 


At the same time, women disproportionately became targets for lobotomisation. Out of Freeman’s first twenty psychosurgery patients, seventeen of them were women. From the 1940s through the mid-1950s, men slightly outnumbered women as patients in state hospitals, yet female patients made up 60 percent of those who underwent lobotomies. 


The belief that a woman’s natural state was to be an obedient wife and devoted mother, and that any deviation from this was an effect of a disordered mind, has been repeated depressingly throughout the history of androcentric western medicine. In the book Unwell Women: Misdiagnosis and Myth in a Man-Made World written by Elinor Cleghorn, she writes, “In an era when a mentally healthy woman was a serene wife and mother, almost any behaviour or emotion that disrupted domestic harmony could be interpreted as justification for a lobotomy.”


Lobotomies were also used on a large proportion of women diagnosed women with ‘hysteria’, an alleged mental health condition that explained any behaviours that made men… uncomfortable. A fondness for writing and even infertility could fall easily under the umbrella of ‘female hysteria’.


While the rise of the lobotomy was slow and sequential, its demise seems to have happened rapidly. Named the most brutal, barbaric and infamous medical precedure of all time, several countries banned the procedure altogether in the 1970s. 

Comments

Most Popular

‘Make Tattooing Safe Again’: Sheffield Based Tattoo Artist Exposed for Indecent Behaviour

 by Emily Fletcher TW: SA, Animal Abuse, Transphobia Photo Credit: @ meiko_akiz uki Recently, an  Instagram account  has been created to provide a  ‘space to safely give a voice to those who want to speak out about the behaviour of one, Sheffield based tattoo artist’. A  total of 40+ posts have been made by the above social media account regarding  one of Sheffield's most popular tattoo artists .  Thankfully, all posts are prefaced with a Content Warning prior to sharing screenshots of the messages that have been sent anonymously to the page. The majority of Content Warnings refer to sexual behaviour, abuse, and sexual assault. It is clear that there is a reoccurring theme within each submission, as many clients appear to have had the same experiences with the tattoo artist. Women, mostly, are being made to feel uncomfortable while being tattooed. One of the most vulnerable positions anyone can be in, tattoo artists should make their clients feel comfortable and safe during the pro

Single Review: ‘Tell Me’ - Jay Moussa-Mann

by Ilana Hawdon The feeling of pure betrayal and heartbreak is perfectly captured in Jay Moussa-Mann’s latest single, ‘Tell Me’. Jay Moussa-Mann is the folk dream we have been waiting for. A favourite on BBC Introducing, Radio 6 and BBC Radio Tees, Jay ’s sound is easy on the ears but delightfully addictive. With a background in writing and film, she began her solo musical venture when she released her debut album, ‘Little Deaths’ in late-2019, and since then, Moussa-Mann has defined herself as an artist with unbelievable range and promise.    ‘Tell Me’ is completely timeless; with notes of Carole King and Joni Mitchell, Moussa-Mann creates a folk-inspired track which is simultaneously heart wrenching and strangely empowering. Beginning as a simple guitar tune, ‘Tell Me’ builds with layers of luscious strings and twinkling piano, tied together with Jay ’s vocal line which is equal parts melancholic and divine. The song feels unwaveringly intimate; the lyrics ask, ‘what was I worth?’

Eurydice’s Last Words

by Kate Bradley I do not want to return To sit in the stalls, Of an empty black box Strewn with petals Leave the ghost light on, Let it shine like a call home, But I will not come back To turn it off alone. I learn this as we walk Our ever so solemn path Our thudding funeral march, You think we’re going back. As I trace my old steps, I fear of the day When the symphony swells, And I land my gaze On you, yet you will be Enraptured by the sound, If you did twist To turn around, You would not see me. So I am not sorry, I speak out into the empty air And I am not sorry. “Turn Around.” You do, you look You think  I fall But I run on, Arms wide open To fall in love With it all “Perhaps she was the one who said, ‘Turn around.” On the X45 bus, back from the Tyneside Cinema, I wrote a poem entitled “Eurydice’s Final Words”, after having seen “Portrait of a Lady on Fire”.  That poem was terrible, so I wrote a new one, as my response to the beautifully poignant film.  In one scene, Héloïse , an 1