Skip to main content

Jane Austen, Girlhood, and the Witty Rom-Com

by Oana-Maria Moldovan

When romantic comedies inspired by classic literature started being popular, in the middle of the Shakespearean haze one other writer provided a base for creating timeless movies: Jane Austen. 

Just like their movie counterparts, Austen wrote classic literary novels with more wittiness, sarcasm, and fun, showing girlhood from a new perspective.

In a period when texts for and about women played a pivotal role in shaping societal perceptions – because there were so few of them – Jane Austen crafted certain tales that transcended conventional norms and the beauty of being a woman.

Austen’s works were significant in the 18th and 19th centuries and cannot be overstated as they provided a nuanced exploration of womanhood, expectations within society, and individual agency.

Jane Austen wrote about real women, with faults and vices. The writer pictured women so devastatingly true to the source material that some ended up being hated – take Lydia Bennet as an example.

A universal experience of girlhood is watching Amy Heckerling’s ‘Clueless’ during our formative years (I was 14). And with that viewing came the fact that its book equivalent, ‘Emma,’ was the worst novel written by Austen. 

I don’t know about others, but for me it was love at first sight - with the both Clueless and Emma. 

Emma, the character, was, once upon a time, even more hated than Lydia Bennet. Emma is a very clueless young girl, thinking she can easily meddle in anyone’s life because “she knows best.”

For instance, her well-intentioned but misguided matchmaking attempts, like pairing up Harriet Smith and Mr. Elton, often resulted in comedic chaos, making her a character that readers and viewers found both charming and exasperating.

Emma is twenty-one and embodies each and every one of us during those early adulthood ages.

Cher Horowitz, played by Alicia Silverstone, Austen’s Emma Woodhouse movie counterpart, showcased that there is no singular mold for girlhood. 

The 1995 movie was set in the high-rich end of Beverly Hills, California. Her father was a well-paid lawyer, mirroring the wealthy Mr. Woodhouse from books. She was a spoiled and popular cliché.

Cher, akin to Emma, embraces her unique personality traits, challenging the conventional portrayal of women in literature. 

This film mirrors Austen’s satire, respecting its story above changing it, and underscores the importance of identity and self-discovery for young women.

It’s the same formula that works so well for most rom-coms. We have a teenage girl (bonus points for having one parent dead), the WOC (woman of colour) best friend – and her boyfriend –, the new student, and as many stereotypes as one can fit in a film (the stoner, the posh guy, the gay best friend, and so on). All of this film’s figures are an ode to their book’s analogs.

We also have a slightly inappropriate relationship between the two step-siblings. Although, because it’s a silly fun movie and a good reimagination of “Emma,” hastily it almost works.

Both the movie and the original text created a space where girls were allowed to be girls, to make mistakes, to learn along the way, and to not have a clue about life. These characters are seen as annoying because they are supposed to be. 

Everyone was a bit annoying at this age, and Austen, with all the criticism that she faced, allowed girls to be as annoying as boys.

Another enduring adaptation, Sharon Maguire’s ‘Bridget Jones’s Diary’ pays homage to Jane Austen’s legacy of multifaceted female roles by transposing “Pride and Prejudice” to modern-day London. 

Renée Zellweger’s portrayal of Bridget Jones embodies the spirit of Elizabeth Bennet, a character celebrated for her wit and resilience.

In a society that often prescribed a singular narrative for women, Elizabeth Bennet challenged stereotypes and Bridget Jones continued this tradition.

The 2001 film not only reinterprets the classic love story but also reinforces the importance of embracing one’s imperfections and own journey in life, echoing Austen’s timeless message of women’s agency and self-determination.

What I think most people love about this movie is its interpretation of its source material. The director took Mr. Darcy’s infamous line (meeting Elizabeth and stating “she was not very handsome,” referring to the fact that she was rather ordinary looking) and ran with it.

Renée Zellweger is clearly a beautiful woman, but her character in the movie is made out to be seen as a plain Jane – a thing that was later reflected in the way the media viewed the actress. Despite this fatphobia from the noughties, Austen’s original text allowed women to have heart-wrenching and soul-consuming love stories - without them having to be the most beautiful to do so.

Jane Austen did this thing with her characters; she gave them personalities – which was not a common trait for women in literature at that period. Her women were permitted to be smarter, braver, more insightful, and more sarcastic than any man in any room.

Yes, this is the most famous plot of “will they, won’t they”. The story of a gloomy and prideful Mr. Darcy and an almost rebellious (for her times) and prejudiced Lizzie Bennet. It is also a chronicle about sisterhood, being a young girl, love, compassion, friendship, family dynamics, and societal misconduct.

Jane Austen’s significance lies not only in her masterful storytelling but also in her revolutionary creation of varied female figures. When normative expectations constrained women, Austen’s novels presented readers with a spectrum of personalities, from the spirited and thoughtful Elizabeth Bennet to the flawed yet endearing Emma Woodhouse.

Austen’s commitment to portraying women authentically resonates in contemporary cinema through adaptations like ‘Clueless’ and ‘Bridget Jones’s Diary’ which demonstrate the enduring influence of Jane Austen’s work. 

These films navigate the complexities of girlhood, championing variety, and individuality, mirroring Austen’s groundbreaking approach to female roles when readers are assured that there is no singular way to be a woman.

By creatively reinterpreting Austen’s themes and characters, these films contribute to the ongoing narrative on the importance of celebrating the multifaceted representations of femininity.

They are great love stories, however, they are even greater tales about being a young woman.

Edited by Emily Duff

Most Popular

‘Make Tattooing Safe Again’: Sheffield Based Tattoo Artist Exposed for Indecent Behaviour

 by Emily Fletcher TW: SA, Animal Abuse, Transphobia Photo Credit: @ meiko_akiz uki Recently, an  Instagram account  has been created to provide a  ‘space to safely give a voice to those who want to speak out about the behaviour of one, Sheffield based tattoo artist’. A  total of 40+ posts have been made by the above social media account regarding  one of Sheffield's most popular tattoo artists .  Thankfully, all posts are prefaced with a Content Warning prior to sharing screenshots of the messages that have been sent anonymously to the page. The majority of Content Warnings refer to sexual behaviour, abuse, and sexual assault. It is clear that there is a reoccurring theme within each submission, as many clients appear to have had the same experiences with the tattoo artist. Women, mostly, are being made to feel uncomfortable while being tattooed. One of the most vulnerable positions anyone can be in, tattoo artists should make their clients feel comfortable and safe during the pro

Now What? The Aftermath of the 'Manic Pixie Dream Girl'

by Susan Moore Here is a bit about me: I am an open, excitable, creative AFAB who is also moderately attractive. I have a unique sense of personal style and a personality that on the surface can only be described as “bubbly” and “quirky”. For this reason, dating is a nightmare. To be sure, I do not have a hard time finding dates or potential suitors. The problems arise when said dates spend some time with me and decide that I am a rare specimen, and the connection they feel with me is “unlike anything they have felt before”. Then, things go one of two ways.  Either a) they decide I am too high maintenance and no longer palatable, or  b) they choose to never look further than the surface and are content to date the idea of me rather than the real me. There is something rather interesting, perhaps funny, about my situation. It is in no way unique. I have met so many people who constantly dealt with the same problem. Even funnier still, is the fact that there is a trope that simultaneousl

Eurydice’s Last Words

by Kate Bradley I do not want to return To sit in the stalls, Of an empty black box Strewn with petals Leave the ghost light on, Let it shine like a call home, But I will not come back To turn it off alone. I learn this as we walk Our ever so solemn path Our thudding funeral march, You think we’re going back. As I trace my old steps, I fear of the day When the symphony swells, And I land my gaze On you, yet you will be Enraptured by the sound, If you did twist To turn around, You would not see me. So I am not sorry, I speak out into the empty air And I am not sorry. “Turn Around.” You do, you look You think  I fall But I run on, Arms wide open To fall in love With it all “Perhaps she was the one who said, ‘Turn around.” On the X45 bus, back from the Tyneside Cinema, I wrote a poem entitled “Eurydice’s Final Words”, after having seen “Portrait of a Lady on Fire”.  That poem was terrible, so I wrote a new one, as my response to the beautifully poignant film.  In one scene, Héloïse, an 18